For the best experience on desktop, install the Chrome extension to track your reading on news.ycombinator.com
Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | history | Nolski's commentsregister

This is a good idea. Do you have a package in mind?


Depends on the size you want to tackle. Let's shoot for MIT licensed or similar, so we don't have to do the unethical thing.

ESLint or Webpack would probably be attempts that are decently sized for a challenge.

Cheerio would be a bit smaller.

Chalk is probably close to the absolute lower bound of what's even meaningful. (You'd likely just regenerate a package that size from scratch instead of wondering about compat)


Upload your manifest and find out! :)


What makes this service not real?


It makes me really happy to see this comment :)


Yes. Provided you had access to the original source code. Pheonix technologies did this with the IBM bios.


Strange. This is exactly how I made malus.sh


Is it satire? Or is it a warning?


If it's a warning, it's a warning that also delivers the thing it's warning about.


It's described on the web page but it's by having 2 agents. One has access to the code and one doesn't.


Are they the same model?

Not that it matters, I just think the joke is more fun if they are different.


It depends. Although they always have entirely separate contexts.



It works. It is hooked up to Stripe. You can upload your package.json and receive a fully cleanroomed set of dependencies to use yourself. It is up to you to determine whether this is a compelling product or a warning to those who care about FOSS.


Would be nice if it could clean-room replace proprietary software too. Would require automating the procedure this person did:

https://reorchestrate.com/posts/your-binary-is-no-longer-saf... https://reorchestrate.com/posts/your-binary-is-no-longer-saf...


I do like this idea, more difficult to do without access to the original source code, and I think that this would be more "reverse engineering" rather than cleanrooming, as you don't have the same concerns about copyright violation if you're working from a binary.


I think the same copyright concerns apply when working with binaries, which is why clean-room reverse-engineering was invented in the first place. So that no disassembled/decompiled code could be copied into the newly created codebase.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clean-room_design

It would be a combination of reverse engineering and clean rooming, assisted with FOSS tools and LLMs; run NSA Ghidra to decompile the binary, LLM-clean the output code, LLM-generate the clean-room spec, LLM-verify the clean-room spec is not copyright infringing, LLM-generate code from the clean-room spec.


It's a satire, if you google the authors it's even more clear.


oh you ARE the author.

ok


Is it satire if it actually works and you can pay real money for it?


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search:

HN For You