For the best experience on desktop, install the Chrome extension to track your reading on news.ycombinator.com
Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | history | more dfgfek's commentsregister

In the EU, hate crime laws. (Just to be clear, I think it's unfortunate that it's likely illegal - I disagree with the parent post)


How does it violate hate crime laws? This just seem a privacy problem.


This is not in the EU


I know, but TFA says that some of the people recording are coming from Europe.


People from the EU still have first amendment rights within the US


Yes but if they post the videos and then go back to the EU (since they live there) I assume they can get in trouble.


Can they? If a person from France uses weed in California, will France get mad?

Seems kinda silly to enforce a country's laws on someone even when they're in another country. I guess social media makes it kind of a gray area though, since the violating act might be the upload itself (which can happen anywhere and is essentially 'continuous' even when the uploader returns to their home country).


It depends on the law where you're from. US citizens are sometimes surprised that they can be prosecuted by the US for crimes they've committed abroad, even when it's not a crime in the place where it happened. The term for this is "extraterritorial jurisdiction".


> Seems kinda silly to enforce a country's laws on someone even when they're in another country.

It's relatively common these days. The US assumes global jurisdiction for anything that touches the US Dollar (as e.g. Kim Dotcom of Megaupload has been fighting for years now), and most Western nations assume global jurisdiction for a select few grave crimes (mostly murder, war crimes and sexual exploitation of underagers).


They could. An American could say unsavory things about the Thai monarch in New York and end up getting into trouble when she travels to Thailand years later.


I am pretty sure Pakistan has this for blasphemy too.


Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search:

HN For You