For the best experience on desktop, install the Chrome extension to track your reading on news.ycombinator.com
Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | history | theletterf's commentsregister

The Windows 3.1 theme of my blog says Hi: https://passo.uno/win31/fine-tuning-docs-llm/

Hi! Love it. The sound effects are a great touch. :)

Ha! I didn't know the origin was Shannon. It makes sense now. Big fan of my namesake Bellard. :]


Interesting! I think the advantage of style fine-tuning is that you might not have to provides that much context upfront. Also, it's kind of magical to have an LLM just do something out of the box. I'll compare my local fine-tuned models against the baseline with instructions and see how they fare.

Yes, TBH one of the reasons i want to try and finetune my own is to teach it stuff that now i have to explain before anything can be done :-P.

Unfortunately i only have a 24GB GPU - and an AMD one at that - so there isn't much i can do on that front. Supposedly a 24GB GPU is enough for finetuning a 24B model with 4bit QLoRA, though when i tried it with some finetuning app (in an official docker container) it barfed at Mistral's weird template or something and i lost interest after that.


Try Runpod or similar services: you can fine-tune stuff for the price of a latte. Stanford's NLP course recommends them: https://cs336.stanford.edu/

I've heard about this but i prefer to avoid anything cloud based (not just for AI but in general). I try to avoid relying on stuff i have little to no control over.

Had to pick a year, and most of the material hovers around the mid-90s, the golden age of MS docs. And 1995 is THE Microsoft year. :)

Author here. Sorry, should have made that more visible!

Not at all. It was there, and my bad that for some reason I didn’t initially see it :)

Author here. Another trick, I would argue, is consistency, hence the focus on style.

I also wrote on what I think makes docs beautiful, by the way! https://passo.uno/what-makes-docs-beautiful/


I sometimes long for audio feedback when interacting with Claude, so I've made a Claude Code hook that makes Claude reply to negative feedback with sounds from a folder. You can use any sound you want.

@dang Is this item getting a lot of negative votes? I've no way of knowing, other than seeing my kharma increasing only slightly after all the points the story collected.

Votes (particularly on submissions over comments) do not directly translate to karma. I'm not sure if it's documented anywhere what the algorithm is, but it's something proportionate to the logarithm of post votes becomes profile karma. It's similar with comments, but I believe (anecdata and observation) the positive effect of votes on karma is also logarithmic, but the negative effects of downvotes is linear; so if you have a highly controversial comment that sits at 1-2 points, you can net lose account karma.

Thanks! That makes sense. This was just genuine curiosity on how HN works, I couldn't care less about kharma.

There is no downvoting on posts, only flags.

For a moment I pictured the Jesuits training their own LLM. If Arthur C. Clarke was still alive, we'd read a story like The Star, but with AI as the main plot device.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Star_%28Clarke_short_story...


Forgive me if this isn't what you meant, but a Jesuit has trained his own LLM:

https://www.magiscenter.com/magisai

From the "Core Features" tab: "Trusted sourcebase: answers are consistent with Catholic Church Teaching and the most contemporary scholarship in science, philosophy, history, scriptural exegesis, social science, and theology."

The Jesuit priest behind this is Fr. Robert J. Spitzer, S.J., Ph.D.

https://www.magiscenter.com/father-spitzer

I haven't used magisAI, but I've read a small to fair amount of Fr. Spitzer's writings, and also seen and heard some of his videos and podcasts (largely from his show Fr. Spitzer's Universe), and probably qualify as a big fan of his.

https://ondemand.ewtn.com/Home/Series/ondemand/video/en/fr-s...

https://www.ewtn.com/tv/shows/father-spitzers-universe

P.S. In case you are wondering about the glasses he wears or his appearance in photographs, he suffers near blindness due to retinitis pigmentosa:

https://www.magiscenter.com/blog/latest-news-on-fr-spitzers-... [2018]

EDIT: Formatting.


Ah, an opening to recommend The Sparrow by Mary Doria Russell, about a Jesuit going to space to speak with aliens. It won the Arthur C Clarke Award in 1998. I read it recently and it has stuck with me very strongly!

Now I’m thinking of “The Nine Billion Names of God” (which I actually read because someone here linked it!) and I’m a little nervous lol

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search:

HN For You